Problems viewing this email? Click Here

600px_FCS-IntelligenceTopper-New
January 29, 2015  

 
 Q&A of the Week

New Owner of Old Condominium with Improvements and Betterments

A Ohio subscriber recently asked the following question:

When a condo owner makes improvements to the condo, for example new kitchen cabinets, and later sells the condo, are the cabinets still betterments and improvements for the new owner who purchases the condo?

ANSWER: The condo policy does not define "improvements and betterments." The policy provides coverage for betterments and alterations. While the new owner did not make the alterations, they are still alterations all the same. Also, the state statutes determine whether the unit owner or the condo association is responsible for appliances and cabinets. In our opinion the alterations still count as alterations under the new owner and should be insured as such.

 
 Litigation Watch
Replacement of Damaged Property

A dispute arose between the insurer and the insured as to whether the policy language providing for the replacement of damaged property with property of comparable material and quality required the replacement of undamaged siding in order to provide a color match. This case is Cedar Bluff Townhome Condominium Ass'n v. American Family Mut. Ins. Co. No. A13-0124, 2014 WL 7156914 (Minn. Dec. 17, 2014).

During a hail storm, Cedar Bluff's buildings sustained some damage. Roofs were damaged and at least one siding panel on each building sustained damage. The siding was about eleven years old and the color of the panels had faded. Replacement panels were available from the same manufacturer but the panels were not available in the same color.

Cedar Bluff, the insured, submitted a claim. The insurer, American Family, did not dispute that the hail storm damaged the panels. A dispute did arise regarding the value of the loss. Cedar Bluff argued that all of the siding on each building had to be replaced because there would be a color mismatch with the existing panels if only the damaged siding panels were replaced. American Family offered to pay for replacement panels that were either slightly darker or slightly lighter in color than the original panels.

The insured demanded an appraisal, and the appraisal panel found that the original siding of the buildings could be matched in terms of model name, texture, size, and installation, but could not be matched in terms of color. The panel determined the award for total replacement of the siding was $361,108. The insurer refused to pay the appraisal award. The insured sued and the trial court ruled in favor of the insurer. A court of appeals reversed and the dispute went to the Supreme Court of Minnesota.

The Supreme Court granted review to determine if the appraisal panel properly concluded that American Family's obligation to replace damaged property with property of comparable material and quality required it to replace damaged and undamaged property to achieve a color match.

The court noted that the policy required replacement cost to be determined based on the cost to replace lost or damaged property with other property of comparable material and quality. The insurer argued the comparable means similar, not identical and therefore it was not obligated to replace all of the siding panels simply because it was unable to replace the damaged siding panels with panels that were an identical color match to the originally installed panels. The insured countered that comparable requires a color match and since the insurer could not replace the damaged siding panels to provide a color match, it was obligated to replace all of the panels.

The court said the dictionary defines "comparable" as "similar or equivalent, suitable for matching or coordinating." Thus, the plain meaning of the phrase "comparable material and quality" is material that is suitable for matching; in other words, a reasonable color match between new and existing siding is required. The court noted that the replacement siding panels could not be matched in terms of color, so the question then became: is the color mismatch direct physical loss of or damage to covered property?

American Family said that the term "physical damage" means a distinct, demonstrable, and physical alteration. The court ruled that because of the color mismatch resulting from the inability to replace the hail-damaged siding panels with siding of comparable material and quality, the covered property (the buildings) had sustained a distinct, demonstrable, and physical alteration. The court concluded that Cedar Bluff had sustained a covered loss and the insured was entitled to have all of the siding panels on each of its buildings replaced. The appraisal panel's award was affirmed.

Editor's Note: The Supreme Court of Minnesota ruled that the insurer's obligation to replace damaged property with property of comparable material and quality required it to replace damaged and undamaged siding panels to achieve a reasonable color match.
 
   
 Subscribe to FC&S
FC&S Online is the unquestioned authority on insurance coverage interpretation and anlaysis for the P&C industry. FC&S offers unbiased analysis and interpretation and keeps you current on the latest ISO and AAIS revisions. Providing instant access to the very latest information, FC&S is the resource that agents, attorneys, brokers, risk managers, underwriters, and adjusters rely on to research commercial and personal lines coverage issues.
Quickly and accurately determine coverage under a policy at the time of loss
Research coverage issues and interpretations, including court cases
Access experts live to discuss specific situations
Find answers to questions based on real-world claims disputes
View and print ISO forms
Access updates on breaking litigation and bureau developments
160px_Start-Your-Free-Trial
 
 Join Us Live!
FC&S editors regularly conduct web-based demos of the service. Feel free to contact Christine Barlow, cbarlow@ SummitProNets.com, for more information. They only take 30 minutes, a small investment of time that will help you learn all that FC&S Online has to offer.
 
 Contact Us
As always, your comments and questions are welcome.

Contact us at:
FC&S Department
Phone: 800-543-0874
Fax: 859-692-2246
Email: eAlerts@nuco.com
 
The Zalma Insurance Claims Library
293px_FCS_ZalmaComboImage  
Insurance Claims: A Comprehensive Guide
The only source you'll need to successfully handle insurance claims from start to finish. More Info
Construction Defects Coverage Guide
Your single-source for identifying, insuring, investigating, prosecuting, and defending cases that result from construction defect claims. More Info
Mold Claims Coverage Guide
This guide will allow you to handle mold insurance claims and litigation resulting from mold or fungi related disputes with confidence. More Info
For more information about these titles Click Here
 
FC&S Team
Kelly Maheu, J.D.
Publisher
  Diane W. Richardson, CPCU
Consulting Editor
Christine G. Barlow, CPCU
Managing Editor, FC&S
  Diana B. Reitz, CPCU, AAI
Consulting Editor
David D. Thamann, J.D., CPCU, ARM
Managing Editor, FC&S Bulletins
  Katherine S. Caudill, J.D.
Manager of Product Development
Susan L. Massmann, CPCU
Managing Editor, Electronic Publications
  Emily Brunner
Online Print/Production Editor
Donald S. Malecki, CPCU
Contributing Editor
  Tosha Brinkman
Marketing Manager
Barry Zalma, Esq., CFE
Contributing Editor
  Donna Cozatchy
Creative Director
This publication is designed to provide accurate and authoritative information in regard to the subject matter covered. It is sold with the understanding that the publisher is not engaged in rendering legal, accounting or other professional service. If legal advice is required, the services of a competent professional person should be sought.

To ensure future delivery of email, please add admin@list.nationalunderwriter.com
to your address book, contacts or safe sender list.

You have received this email at %%merge members_.emailaddr_%%.
Click here to unsubscribe from %%merge list.descshort%%.
©2015 Summit Professional Networks, All rights reserved. Privacy Policy
 
160px_SummitPN
4157 Olympic Blvd., Suite 225
Erlanger, KY 41018
1-800-543-0874